Speeches, Interviews & Other Statements

Complete list of 8,000+ Thatcher statements & texts of many of them

1978 May 11 Th
Margaret Thatcher

House of Commons PQs

Document type: speeches
Document kind: House of Commons PQs
Venue: House of Commons
Source: Hansard HC [949/1395-1401]
Journalist: -
Editorial comments: 1515-1530.
Importance ranking: Major
Word count: 2348
Themes: Foreign policy (Western Europe - non-EU), Terrorism
[column 1395]

TUC AND CBI

Q1. Mr. Joseph Dean

asked the Prime Minister when he next plans to meet the Confederation of British Industry.

The Prime Minister (Mr. James Callaghan)

I met representatives of the CBI on 6th February and further meetings will be arranged as necessary.

Mr. Dean

When my right hon. Friend next meets the leaders of the CBI, will he remind them of the substantial financial assistance that members of the CBI in Northern Ireland and Scotland receive from the Government? How does he relate this to the members of the CBI from those areas who this week have induced Unionist and SNP Members to vote against the Government in an attempt to wreck their financial and economic strategy? Is it not time that the situation in relation to these two areas of the United Kingdom was reviewed?

The Prime Minister

The people of both Scotland and Northern Ireland are very well aware of the importance and significance of public expenditure to support the superstructure of their economies. Certainly I shall remind [column 1396]the leaders of the CBI, and anyone else who wishes to be reminded of that fact, when I meet them, but I have a feeling that last night and on Monday some of the voting was not necessarily directed to the merits of the issue but was an attempt to pressurise—I would not want to use the word “blackmail” —the Government into making concessions that they would not otherwise make.

Mr. Pardoe

Is the Prime Minister aware that it is not only in the matter of taxation that the CBI wants an out break of parliamentary democracy and greater parliamentary control? Is he aware that the CBI is asking that this House should intervene on levels of pay in the future pay policy? What does the Prime Minister think about a Select Committee of this House on pay, as the CBI has suggested?

The Prime Minister

I can think of few worse things.

Miss Boothroyd

When my right hon. Friend next meets the CBI, will he ask for progress reports on the new code of conduct for British firms with subsidiaries in South Africa so that he might see to what extent those subsidiaries are implementing that code of conduct in order to bring about better employment procedures for black African workers there?

The Prime Minister

There has been discussion between the Foreign Secretary and other Ministers and the CBI on this matter, and I believe that a code of conduct has been agreed by the Council of Foreign Ministers of the European Community. I shall bring my hon. Friend's question to the attention of the Foreign Secretary so that this can be taken up with the CBI, if it has not been taken up already.

Sir David Renton

When the Prime Minister sees the leaders of the CBI, will he tell them how much longer he intends to govern or attempt to govern when he is unable to persuade the House of Commons to carry out the policy that has been decided upon by the Cabinet?

The Prime Minister

No. I think it quite improper to discuss that matter with the CBI.

Q3. Mr. Ward

asked the Prime Minister when he next plans to meet the Trades [column 1397]Union Congress and the Confederation of British Industries.

The Prime Minister

I met representatives of both the TUC and the CBI when I took the chair at a meeting of the NEDC on 1st February. Further meetings will be arranged as necessary.

Mr. Ward

Now that my right hon. Friend has had discussions with Chancellor Schmidt, what special measures will he be urging upon organised labour to contribute towards the problem of giving every unemployed man, woman and young person purposeful work, in view of the fact that the situation will be very difficult for several years to come?

The Prime Minister

This is a situation in which combined action by the European Governments, as well as an exchange of our experiences, would be extremely helpful. As the Chancellor told me, the situation in Germany is not good in terms of unemployment. It is likely to be difficult for all of us to return to full employment. I cannot give my hon. Friend a detailed answer in the space of a supplementary reply, but he is aware of the many measures that have been taken in this country and the similar measures that are being taken in other countries.

Mr. Tapsell

When the Prime Minister next meets the TUC and CBI, will he explain to them why, at a time when we have 1½ million people unemployed in this country, the Government have just introduced a Budget the immediate effect of which has been to force up interest rates very substantially, thus making it more expensive for industry to provide the new investment necessary to restore high levels of employment?

The Prime Minister

I do not know whether the hon. Gentleman wishes to reverse the vote that he recorded last night. If he really believes what he has said, he should have been with us rather than with the Opposition. With regard to interest rates, I am always a little careful about pronouncing on the market. I stick to the general proposition that the market is not always right, and it may not be right on this occasion, either.

Mr. Canavan

In view of the concern of the trade union movement about the Lonrho bid to take over Scottish and Universal Investments, will my right [column 1398]hon. Friend give an assurance that the Government will not simply stand by and allow the job prospects of thousands of Scottish workers to be sold out to a multinational concern which is the subject of a Fraud Squad investigation because of alleged Rhodesian sanctions busting? Will my right hon. Friend, therefore, make sure that we have an early statement on this matter?

The Prime Minister

Concern in Scotland has been expressed to me about this proposed takeover. I think that I should leave it to my right hon. Friend the Secretary of State for Prices and Consumer Affairs to consider whether this matter should be referred to the Monopolies Commission. I am sure that he will then make a statement.

Mr. Montgomery

When the Prime Minister does meet the TUC, will he be able to tell it how many snoopers he thinks will have to be recruited to investigate self-financing productivity deals?

The Prime Minister

No. We usually discuss serious matters.

Mr. George Rodgers

When my right hon. Friend meets the CBI, will he inquire why it is that senior members of that organisation persistently make pessimistic and melancholy forecasts about the future of British industry? Is not that surprising, in view of the concessions that have been made by this Government to the CBI's viewpoint? Is it not a fact that members of that organisation seem to spend half their time asking for Government financial support and the rest of their time resenting the intrustion by the Government into industry?

The Prime Minister

I have my criticisms of the CBI, and I dare say that the CBI has its criticisms of me. On the whole, I prefer to try to work with it rather than to attack it, because I believe that the future of British industry is vital to our economic prosperity as a whole. I shall, of course, miss no opportunity of asking the CBI to be less gloomy. But when the CBI talks to me, it seems to take the view that it is the media which are spreading gloom about our prospects. On ocasion the CBI asks whether we cannot do something about it. I always reply that this is a free country, as is well known.

[column 1399]

PRIME MINISTER

(ENGAGEMENTS)

Q2. Mr. Noble

asked the Prime Minister if he will list his public engagements for 11th May.

The Prime Minister

This morning I presided at a meeting of the Cabinet. In addition to my duties in this House, I shall be holding meetings with ministerial colleagues and others. Later today I shall be leaving for a visit to North-West England. I should like to inform the House that I propose to call at the Italian Embassy immediately after Questions to convey the condolences of Her Majesty's Government on the tragic and brutal murder of Signor Aldo Moro. I am sure that I speak for every hon. Member in offering our deepest sympathy to Signor Moro 's widow and family and in paying tribute to one who was an outstanding leader of his country.

Mr. Noble

When my right hon. Friend visits the Italian Embassy, will he express, in addition to our sorrow, the outrage of Members of this House at the violence that has taken place in Italy in recent years, and particularly in the case of this brutal murder? When he goes to the North-West, will he explain to the many trade unionists and workers whom he will meet there the anti-working-class nature of the amendments that were passed through this House this week? In particular, will he explain to them that if a Tory Government had their way, this would have been at the expense of financial assistance to industry, which would lead to large-scale unemployment in the North-West?

The Prime Minister

I find it difficult to combine answers to both those supplementary questions. I should like to content myself by saying that I wrote to Signor Andreotti, the Italian Prime Minister. I told him that the Government—and, I know, the British people as a whole—remain determined that everything possible shall be done, with the Italian Government and other democratic Governments, to protect the rights of individuals and the foundations of our democratic institutions—in Italy and elsewhere—from this terrible threat that has been posed by terrorist violence.

[column 1400]

Mrs. Thatcher

May I join with James Callaghanthe Prime Ministerin the tribute which he has just paid to Signor Moro? I join with him in condemning the callous and brutal murder which took place. We Conservatives would also like to be associated with the condolences to Signor Moro 's family and friends. We should also like to express our understanding of the very difficult decisions that faced his colleagues during what must also have been a great ordeal for them. Signor Moro was a victim of a kind of war waged upon the free society. Because of what has happened, we hope that the resolve to fight terrorism will be the greater, and the future of the free society and democracy the more sure.

The Prime Minister

I am obliged to the right hon. Lady for the manner in which she has expressed her thoughts on this matter. I shall certainly convey them to the Italian authorities. I am also glad that, in addition to the great sorrow and anguish of the family, she mentioned the ordeal that Signor Moro 's ministerial colleagues have passed through. I hope that any British Government would face such a situation with the same courage as the Italian Government have done.

Q4. Mr. Moate

asked the Prime Minister if he will list his official engagements for 11th May.

The Prime Minister

I refer the hon. Member to the reply which I gave earlier today to my hon. Friend the Member for Rossendale (Mr. Noble).

Mr. Moate

Will the Prime Minister take time today to give a rather better answer to the question put by my right hon. and learned Friend the Member for Huntingdonshire (Sir D. Renton)? When a Government have clearly lost control of their Budget strategy, and when they were made to look as foolish as they were last night, is it not clearly time, in the national interest if not in the Labour Party's interest, for the country to be given a chance to elect a new Government?

The Prime Minister

I am relieved to hear that the hon. Gentleman was considering only the national interest and not what he conceives to be the interest of the Conservative Party on these matters, although he might be wrong even if he [column 1401]thought that. The Government are in control of this matter. I should like to repeat what the Chancellor has said before, namely, that we shall take any action that is necessary, despite the irresponsibility of the Opposition, in order to retain control over the financial situation that has been created by the Opposition's votes.

Mr. Raphael Tuck

Will my right hon. Friend take time off to broadcast to the nation and explain to it that the Conservative Opposition are so narked by his success in pulling this country out of the morass in which he found it when he took office that their leader is dragging a red herring across the trail? She is blowing up an issue to five, six or 10 times its normal size and making an election issue out of it. I refer to immigration. Will he explain this to the electorate, so that it is not fooled when the time comes?

The Prime Minister

Yes, I shall certainly do my best to inform the country about these matters.

Mr. Burden

You will have a hell of a job.

The Prime Minister

Faced, as I am, with this Opposition, I agree with the hon. Member for Rochester—[Hon. Member: “Gillingham.” ] The hon. Member for Gillingham (Mr. Burden). Perhaps Rochester would not have him. The hon. Gentleman has been here a long time, and he had better wait and see. He is always extremely amiable on these matters. As to broadcasting to the nation, if I am to judge from my correspondence I find that whenever these broadcasts take place there is a great surge of support.